Brows are more crucial to a look than you think. Up until the summer, or whenever the whole huge Benefit brow relaunch thingy happened, I barely put anything in my brows. Occasionally I'd set them with gel. I had thought my brows were enough and didn't need to be filled or set, until I started to fill them in and set them...This month I'm using one of the many versions of the Ulta brow pencil.
The Bad: Since it is the first actual pencil product that I've used to fill in my brows, it's a very hard product. I see it as a bad thing because I feel like nothing is actually being filled, but then again I have a very light grip so maybe it's a good combination...Also the spoolie isn't the greatest. It's on the smaller side and I prefer a bigger one.
The Good: The price, obviously, but the color ends up blending in fairly easily with my brows, not too cool or warm, which is a plus.
Overall, it's a meh product, I've tried better and I'm sure I'll try worse. I'd definitely recommend it if you're used to filling in your brows as pencils tend to take more precision, or so I've heard...